Buddah! do you even read what the hell I post...sometimes I wonder... I've been saying from the start "user catching" and "animation catching" are completely different.
Anybody! can let the cpu catch for them and throw to an open receive thats why EA did away with "strafe" on offense to make it more "user friendly" to "everyone" this year... and yes if was as easily as you stated to do "user catching" and If you had all this "user skill" you could and should have defended against "user catching" last year when PPL could "strafe" on offense... but like I've said in my post it was a battle for positioning between the "user controlled" receiver and "user controlled" defender and the best position won that battle. I'll miss those battles this year and that challenge... but not everybody played "elite players" last year and some players prayed upon "newbies" that had no idea how to "user catch" or "user defend" and thats why EA did away with it this year to make Madden "user friendly" to everyone.
The "spectacular catch" and "rocket catch" can still be done this year... even with "strafe" being out of the offense so quite saying that stupid s*** about thats not why it's in the game this year... that was a glitch catch that the CPU did last year... "everybody" hated it and it was a glitch in madden 08.
"Example"
hot route moss to do a streak throw a high bullet pass to the out or inside and hold triangle after receiver gets 15 yrds down Field and 80% of the time they would ether "spectacular catch" or "rocket catch" and not "one time" when you do this do you try and "user control" the receiver cause it was a timing thing to get the glitch to work... some PPL could BOMB and do it but only about 30% of the time because again it was a timing thing and the rush would get to them B4 they could get it off in time... thats one of the many reason everybody "nano blitzed" last year on just about every play last year.
This is why "animation glitch catching" and "user catching" are completely different and have nothing to do with each other what so ever and like I said.... EA! removed "strafe" to make it more "user friendly" to everyone. Have you played NCAA 09? you can "user catch" in that game using "strafe" but the "spectacular catch" and "rocket catch" are hardly even seen... just another "example" that it was a "glitch" that has been toned down from last years games and not the case of "strafe" being remove from madden 09.... they just wanted the game to appeal online to a bigger audience this year and by taken "strafe catching" out of the game and the tightening up the deep pass they have done just that... forcing player to play the short to medium passing game for madden 09. It seems now players score more with defense than there offense but when your a true player you can adapt to the game.... right!