Best madden defensive player ever?

Who and what year was the best ever defensive player in madden history? Ray lewis in madden 2005 was pretty crazy and champ bailey was a dominant player for a long time. Who do you think was the best?

Demarcus Ware has been beyond a beast the last couple of yrs whether running on his side or rushing the QB so i have to say Ware with Sean Taylor 2nd, the yr he died he was a 99 and he was picking a everything off and crushing the RB's in run support, with Champ Bailey being third cause even though he locks down his side of the field you could always go the other way.

This year I would have to give it to Derrick Brown, Pat Watkins, and Cromartie-Rodgers. Last year it was Champ Bailey, Cromartie and Polomalu. Ray Lewis has been a beast since I can remember though.

MADDENKING57 wrote:

Demarcus Ware has been beyond a beast the last couple of yrs whether running on his side or rushing the QB so i have to say Ware with Sean Taylor 2nd, the yr he died he was a 99 and he was picking a everything off and crushing the RB's in run support, with Champ Bailey being third cause even though he locks down his side of the field you could always go the other way.

when in the hell was sean taylor a 99?wasnt he like a 92-93 he died?

I think he was a 99 last year(08) before he was killed. Him and Reed were the only 99 safeties if I remember correctly.

damn i really dont remember that..

Brian Dawkins was a beast this year.

sean taylor was fuckin CRAZY!!!! i loved that man no homo

yeah i know sean taylor was my fav safety back then i was lookin forward to him and laron landry teamin up back there

PATRICK WILLIS... He is the greatest defensive player ever created in a Madden game.

6'1" 240 lbs


90 spd- faster then most running backs
96 acc- Accelerates faster than most wide receivers
88 strength- stronger than most D-linemen
99 stamina- This dude can also run a marathon
99 tackle


If I created a Defensive player I wouldn't make him this good because it wouldn't be fair. I have never seen anyone on defense this stacked.

This is his stats in 10

mario williams in 08, champ in 06, and ray lewis in 05

Lewis in 05 was nasty. I always picked him on my fantasy drafts haha. i liked Ware this year and willis

Dawkins in 06, it was the 2nd year of hit stick and he just created the most fumbles in madden with that hit stick feature.

this should be called the 2nd Best madden defensive player ever cause
everyone knows whose 1st

yea this year patrick willis, nmadi

and always ed reed ...u cant throw his way especially deep balls

I tell ya, I'm terrified of Polamalu this year. Against Pittsburgh I just try to avoid him the whole game and always step out of bounds or cover up if he's going to hit Johnson.

Nnamdi Asomugha.... that guy is a beast.

tuki94 wrote:

mario williams in 08, champ in 06, and ray lewis in 05

sounds about right

Nnamdi Asomugha without a doubt. The guy is a FREAK Corner....

I see the comment about Polomalu. Yo, I watched Polomalu since his college days, cause I'm a huge USC fan, sorry to say it, but I love my team. Polomalu is a very fast ballhawk, but he's no hard hitter...he's really good at tackling low, other then that he don't hit hard like Dawkins, or Sean Taylor R.I.P. EA needs to make his hitting power lower.

i gota give it to my boy ed reed... i dont throw interceptions like ever and that guy will pick me off 3 times a game or i gota be really careful and take sacks a lot more often... u play with the ravens and u scare me enough with ed reed to hurt my offence that is pretty unstoppable..

agree with maddenking57 about Ware. I did like alot of da DBs tho. champ as mod said and and asomugha

JROCK275 wrote:

yea this year patrick willis, nmadi

and always ed reed ...u cant throw his way especially deep balls

Agree, P Willis is the best defensive player in 10, and nmadi..you better throw to the other side. And Ed Reed, enough said

taylor was never 99, the year he died he was 93.

I will say this with great respect to Patrick Willis in 09, Jared Allen in 09 but nnamdi asomugha in madden 2009 could shut your best reciever down every gm.