Maclin vs. Crabtee???

who do you think will have the better rookie season michael crabtree or jeremy maclin?

i think Crabtree will have the better rookie season of the two , i know the eagles have a better passing game and donavan mcnabb but they have way more playmakers n weapons than the niners so Maclin ,and Crabtree with the niners might be the number 1 target in the passing game so i see Crabtree having the better season

maclin the 49ers dont even have an official starting QB yet and on top of that they plan to be a more rushing oriented team so that will impact crabtree's numbers the eagles pass more than run so thats more chances for maclin to touch the ball so maclin all day

Got to love DH-B isnt in this convo.

D H B cant compare to maclin or crabtree hes just fast not good
and besides Jamarcus Russel sucks bad more than alex smith lol

lol u guys kno i have to post in here

i dont kno who will have the better rookie season though

if crabtree shows he can start in the preseason he will be the better rookie easily but right now hes like our 4th wr after bruce and morgan and bradon jones he should pass morgan or jones and be slot this year but idk


DARRIUS HEYWARD-BEY SUCKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

ill say maclin because he is alot faster or kinda the same in my opinion because maclin is a special teams god and crabtree i s a beastly WR but maclin has a better QB to throw to him and better players to block for him on kicks and punts.

imma have to pull for my boy maclin

the niners have to prove to me that they can get it done in the air before i can go with crabs

Maclin runs routes just as good as Maclin. Both Maclin and Crabtree are system players... We will have to see how this works out. You can't say JaMarcus sucks seeing as he has no line or a true #1 or #2 receiver.

how is dhb not as good as the other 2. dhb didnt have a good qb in college dhb played in a run 1st pro style offense he was always double teamed. maclin and micheal-i-have-crabs-tree played in a spread offense and they played in a divsion w/ the weakest d in college. dhb's qb threw 4 less then 3,000 yrds while maclin and crabs's qb's threw 4 over 5,000. dont listen 2 the media hype do ur homework b4 u run ur mouth.out crabs or maclin over in mizzoui and c how great there numbers would be.

Fudgy wrote:

LiL MooReR wrote:

Maclin runs routes just as good as Maclin.

???

Maclin has never ran real routes and never had to playing out of a spread offense.

DHB fits the raiders offensive scheme but i believe he will be a bust, no question about it. He's considered a bust in my mind because he shouldn't have been drafted that high in the first place so he's already in the hole. Maclin and Crabtree will both have productive rookie seasons but i would have to give it to maclin solely because of the team he is on, a great running game to open up the pass and a great qb to execute the play

You know what??? I died laughing when I seen those Niner fan's boasting about CRABS like he will be the s***. Your QB situation sucks, and I heard Jamarcus being brought up. He's better then the niner's fudgepacking QB's...You can bring up stats all you want, but the stats were accrued because of a easier schedule. As weak as the NFC west was, the Niner's should of had decent numbers. Come on now.....CRABS will be a bust like Mike Williams. CRABS needs a SPREAD SYSTEM to succeed. And the niner's scheme doesn't fit CRAB's what so ever. As for Maclin, I like the idea of McNabb throwing the ball to him. And with D-Jack there too, Maclin can be dangerous, cause D's will worry about D-Jack more. You Niner fans need to lay off the crack, weed, or whatever booze you guys are hopped up on, cause CRABS will suck. I think DHB will be better then CRABS. **** CRABS. Lousy STD with hands...

jeremy maclin will have a much better season because he has a better QB and player to block when he has the ball

Crabtree

Looks like Maclin will have the better season because CRABTREE DOESNT WANT TO PLAY FOR THE NINERS HAHAHA .

David noooooooo wrote:

Looks like Maclin will have the better season because CRABTREE DOESNT WANT TO PLAY FOR THE NINERS HAHAHA .

yup looks like maclin wins lol

Crabtree of course

...crabtree's hurting himself by holding out...he was going to have tough enough time adapting to a pro style offense....he's going to be a non factor now...

...not to say that jackson's success will mean maclin will make a similar adjustment, but give reid credit for figuring out how to fit a rookie wr into his scheme and coaching him well...that gives maclin the edge...

...as for dhb?...i guezs i'm still waiting for the light to come on in oakland...still waiting...

harvin....

speed kills

maclin the ygot a passing offense niners are a run offense

Spice_Rack101 wrote:

Crabtree of course

haha how can you say crabtree when he isn't even on a team? lol