Most overated and best madden player of all time

All-Pro MS Member Number of posts : 434 Registration date : 2008-07-27

most overated is j rhoads in 08 and secret in 07
but the best i dont know i havent heard about everybody

Moderator Number of posts : 2578 Registration date : 2008-03-10

Have you ever played J Rhoads? Hes actually pretty good.

Moderator Number of posts : 4368 Registration date : 2008-03-12

yo me and my friends have played secret and he aint all that. he won off the dbl wr pass. so i mean he definitely shouldn't have been on madden nation...in my opinion. I don't know who the best is. Also another overrated player is Cdiddy (#1 on ps3) yo i was beating him and he D/C'd me so....that's everyones solution instead of taking a loss.

Moderator Number of posts : 2578 Registration date : 2008-03-10

Fudgy wrote:: yo me and my friends have played secret and he aint all that. he won off the dbl wr pass. so i mean he definitely shouldn't have been on madden nation...in my opinion. I don't know who the best is. Also another overrated player is Cdiddy (#1 on ps3) yo i was beating him and he D/C'd me so....that's everyones solution instead of taking a loss.

Secret did FB Dive plays more than WR Double Pass.

Moderator Number of posts : 4368 Registration date : 2008-03-12

no i was saying that was the play that he did to beat us at the end.

All-Pro MS Member Number of posts : 434 Registration date : 2008-07-27

J rhoads is good i know but coming into 08 after that 07 reign he had he was way overated

Hall of Fame MS Member Number of posts : 1085 Registration date : 2008-05-28

i agree with fudgy cdiddy d/c's all the time i had alot of players who have played him tell me that.

Hall of Fame MS Member Number of posts : 1432 Registration date : 2008-04-07

How is secret over-rated when he won madden nation? lol

Veteran MS Member Number of posts : 602 Registration date : 2008-06-30

BIG GENE FROM PHILLY IS GOOD. HE WON THE TOURNAMENT TWICE. I FORGET WHAT THE TOURNEY IS CALLED, BUT THEY PLAY THE CHAMPIONSHIP AT THE PRO BOWL.

Rookie MS Member Number of posts : 191 Registration date : 2008-03-12

WinkYouOut wrote:: How is secret over-rated when he won madden nation? lol

LMAO THE UNDERDOGS MADE THE FINALS

Exclusive Member Number of posts : 460 Registration date : 2008-08-19

I think I might head to the Madden Challenge in Philly just to see how I stack up you know?

All-Pro MS Member Number of posts : 434 Registration date : 2008-07-27

Secret is ovwerated because he called goalline hb offtackle everyplay

Exclusive Member Number of posts : 2059 Registration date : 2008-08-18

I played secret in person, it was a warm up game before a tourney, he said he wasn't trying that hard but it was 21-21 in the 3rd quarter when we quit to start the real tournament.

Rookie MS Member Number of posts : 236 Registration date : 2008-07-13

Fudgy wrote:: no i was saying that was the play that he did to beat us at the end.

Maybe an eBook to stop that kind of stuff would help out. Smile

Moderator Number of posts : 4368 Registration date : 2008-03-12

eddy that was in madden 08...that glitch aint in 09

Madden School Veteran Number of posts : 2436 Registration date : 2008-11-19

honestly, and this may not mean much...sense i am not a madden tournament type of player....but....i am not impressed with any of those cats. i have heard from friends of mine that do madden tournies that...these cats on tv....are only playing like 2-3 min qrtrs. if that is the case....they are not playing a full 20 minute game. now...i am not saying that they aren't good...but...can they hold up for a full game instead of just that 2-3 minutes that we see edited on tv?

Exclusive Member Number of posts : 1403 Registration date : 2008-11-24

Tvon6Four wrote:: yo me and my friends have played secret and he aint all that. he won off the dbl wr pass. so i mean he definitely shouldn't have been on madden nation...in my opinion. I don't know who the best is. Also another overrated player is Cdiddy (#1 on ps3) yo i was beating him and he D/C'd me so....that's everyones solution instead of taking a loss.

Cdiddy DCed me when he was winning last year. He got a TD to go up 17-14 with 3 minutes left and Dced.

Most underrated is this one guy. Last year he went by RexualChocolate. This year he's Ninnibon. Crazy good player and totally clean.

New MS Member Number of posts : 12 Registration date : 2009-05-17

Well with me being a competiter , i think everyone should think that there the best player out there , imean when i hook up to play someone i sure as hell think im goin to whoop some A no matter who it is

» Most Dynamic Player All Time
» All time favorite Madden Player from any year of madden??
» Most Dominent Madden team of all time?
» FIrst time player,Team to run with????
» New to MS, Long Time Player