Donovan Mcnabb future H.o.F

i've been watching alot football shows and sum experts say if mcnabb could lead the eagles to a superbowl victory he might me be at H.o.F status...i beleive its tru...does anybodii agree or disagree????

I dont think so because his stats dont say that he was consistenly great. He had that one really good year with TO but other than that its just, pretty good. Also he has that glaring flaw in that he has never one a super bowl

so if mcnabb won a superbowl or 2 do u think he would be a h.o.f contender

Its not fair to ask this question yet. 9 years in the league he's only been healthy for 4 of those years. He still could have a legit 5 or 6 years left where he's healthy and earns that HOF status even without a ring cuz when he's healthy he's one of the best in the league. Right now no but if he stays healthy he can definately get there.

yea i def agree

the super bowl while it helps doesnt mean much in determining HOF status. dan marino didnt win won and he's a HOFer.

but mcnabb isnt a hall of famer yet. when you compare him with the two no doubt hall of fame qbs in this era manning and brady his numbers dont even compare. and then you got mcnair and warner as well ahead of him so i dont see him as a HOFer

he is a ****** and inconsistent. unless he gets more consistent he wont be a hall of famer. but if he plays his best every week then he can be

Jim kelly had a very similar past as far as winning goes although he lost 4 straight in the super bowl while mcnabb lost 3 in the nfc championship and one in the SB and kelly got in the HOF but has way better #s then mcnabb too but like I said mcnabb still could have 5-6 years left so who knows.. Its just way too premature to ask this question.

yea i know i just saw it on nfl **** and wanted to c others opinions

if he can win a superbowl and im hoping he will this year he has a good chance