Which one would be better?

Which team style would be better?

A dominate running game like the vikings and the falcons?

OR
A dominate passing game like payton and brady?

The answer to this seems too easy. Superbowls with a passing game and
players like Peyton Manning and Tom Brady or just good enough to get
into the playoffs with guys like AP and Michael Turner? If you couldn't
tell already, I'll take the dominant passing game.

Ketcham while theyre Kobe wrote:

The answer to this seems too easy. Superbowls with a passing game and
players like Peyton Manning and Tom Brady or just good enough to get
into the playoffs with guys like AP and Michael Turner? If you couldn't
tell already, I'll take the dominant passing game.

what ketcham said... its not even close...

It really isnt a fair question because both brady and manning had good running games when they won the superbowl.

And for the record thats Brady 3 Manning 1...but whos counting

crawk wrote:

It really isnt a fair question because both brady and manning had good running games when they won the superbowl.

And for the record thats Brady 3 Manning 1...but whos counting

antoine smith and cory dillon at the end of their careers werent good, they were ok but not good... so u would make the question, elite QB and ok RB or elite RB and ok QB.. still the answer is the same, ill take an elite QB.. having an elite RB and an ok QB would have made us lose the rams superbowl and the carolina superbowl..

Also another problem with the question is the saying "Defense wins Championships"

Case and point is the pats over the rams. Rams had the greatest show on turf, but an average defense prevented them from winning it all.



Also the ravens winning the super bowl in 2000 I think, they won with Trent Dilfer


Then Tom Bradys first super bowl loss (which didnt really happen, the game was never played) was to Eli Manning, who at the time was considered a average to bad QB

crawk wrote:

Then Tom Bradys first super bowl loss (which didnt really happen, the game was never played) was to Eli Manning, who at the time was considered a average to bad QB

exactly, it never happend so lets forget it already!!

forget what?

forget what?

forget what?

sorry about the 3 posts, my computer is screwing up

dominate running game with a great defense
or
dominate passing game with a not so great defense

i say its 50-50 for me because i would love for a team with AP because he could have a 200 yard 3 TD game or a great passer like brady and have a 350 yard game with 4 TDs

Radi0ActivWaste wrote:

i say its 50-50 for me because i would love for a team with AP because he could have a 200 yard 3 TD game or a great passer like brady and have a 350 yard game with 4 TDs

but its alot less common to get a 200 yrd game for a rb than a 300 yrd game for a QB. ill take the passing game without question