MADDEN NFL 11 TOP QB'S

Rodger should be higher than Brady. Even if its Rodgers 93 and Brady 92.

f romo he shouldnt be number 3 or 4 maybe 9 or 8

so much swag wrote:

allain43 wrote:

bigbuddah wrote:

carson palmer should be #10 romo in front of ben and donovan and tom brady #5

WHAT! are you smoking some serious weed cause you have to be fried if you think for one second that choke artist romo should be in front of 2 time superbowl winner ben roethlisberger.

You just a f*cking hater of ROMO! HE shouldnt be nine IMO! he should be number #3 or #4 yeah i said it! and if you want to frank, He should be in the running for M.V.P every year cause he play for the Boy's..holla

yea because he is better then rodgers and rivers right T. Homo is overrated tell me one thing he does better then any other QB in the NFL other then bobble snaps and choke every post season they your boys have sucked so bad that winning 1 playoff game in over 10 years was considered a success for you bums.

Im Sitin Fat Lik Precious wrote:

PeytonMvPManning wrote:

We all knew Peyton was going to be #1 and Brees #2 but i thought Brady would move down to #5 and Rivers #3 and Rodgers to #4

you cant really say they are peyton and brees are 1 and 2 when they are rated the same thing... they both are really #1

actually that isnt true if u ever go into madden n organize players overall the higher 99 will appear up to. brees might have jus hit 99 while manning has stats that barely prevent him from being a 100.

[quote="xXBlackiceXx"]An Early Peek Into Madden NFL 11's Quarterback Ratings

Agility

This attribute was defined as a quarterback's ability to make plays
on his feet. Not necessarily running the ball for positive yards, but
more like keeping the play alive and then making something happen for
his team. This accounts for 10 percent of a quarterback's overall
rating in Madden and it was Vince Young who took home top marks with an
agility rating of 88. Marino, Montana and Brees pretty much all
disagreed with Madden's assessment of Young as the most agile
quarterback, but chances are they've never tried to stop the guy from
the other side of the ball.


ummm... ben roethlisberger?

allain43 wrote:

so much swag wrote:

allain43 wrote:

bigbuddah wrote:

carson palmer should be #10 romo in front of ben and donovan and tom brady #5

WHAT! are you smoking some serious weed cause you have to be fried if you think for one second that choke artist romo should be in front of 2 time superbowl winner ben roethlisberger.

You just a f*cking hater of ROMO! HE shouldnt be nine IMO! he should be number #3 or #4 yeah i said it! and if you want to frank, He should be in the running for M.V.P every year cause he play for the Boy's..holla

yea because he is better then rodgers and rivers right T. Homo is overrated tell me one thing he does better then any other QB in the NFL other then bobble snaps and choke every post season they your boys have sucked so bad that winning 1 playoff game in over 10 years was considered a success for you bums.

Came in the league!!!undrafted then go to the 'PROBOWL' everytime.The only time he did'nt go cause he' was hurt!!!! you need to put a 'ASTERISK' next to your last superbowl's cause you didnt earn them. when we go this year' and win you see what a true CHAMPION look's like....

Schaub can easily put up big numbers just look at his tipicle numbers they look simular to peytons or brady or even brees's #'s.

He was in the top ten in every QB catagory pasing yards,TD's,Completion percentage etc etc schaub is the type of QB thats gonna keep you in the game and play his best when he needs to.

so much swag wrote:

allain43 wrote:

so much swag wrote:

allain43 wrote:

bigbuddah wrote:

carson palmer should be #10 romo in front of ben and donovan and tom brady #5

WHAT! are you smoking some serious weed cause you have to be fried if you think for one second that choke artist romo should be in front of 2 time superbowl winner ben roethlisberger.

You just a f*cking hater of ROMO! HE shouldnt be nine IMO! he should be number #3 or #4 yeah i said it! and if you want to frank, He should be in the running for M.V.P every year cause he play for the Boy's..holla

yea because he is better then rodgers and rivers right T. Homo is overrated tell me one thing he does better then any other QB in the NFL other then bobble snaps and choke every post season they your boys have sucked so bad that winning 1 playoff game in over 10 years was considered a success for you bums.

Came in the league!!!undrafted then go to the 'PROBOWL' everytime.The only time he did'nt go cause he' was hurt!!!! you need to put a 'ASTERISK' next to your last superbowl's cause you didnt earn them. when we go this year' and win you see what a true CHAMPION look's like....

madden ratings have nothing to do with his draft status or wat he has done in his career... new madden ratings = last years football stats...... did romo do better than 22 other starting QBs?

Schaub is gonna be one of the best QB's in madden.

super_mario90 wrote:

Schaub is gonna be one of the best QB's in madden.

Agreed

When the season is over he might move up a few spots.

He should move up a couple spots now

so much swag wrote:

allain43 wrote:

so much swag wrote:

allain43 wrote:

bigbuddah wrote:

carson palmer should be #10 romo in front of ben and donovan and tom brady #5

WHAT! are you smoking some serious weed cause you have to be fried if you think for one second that choke artist romo should be in front of 2 time superbowl winner ben roethlisberger.

You just a f*cking hater of ROMO! HE shouldnt be nine IMO! he should be number #3 or #4 yeah i said it! and if you want to frank, He should be in the running for M.V.P every year cause he play for the Boy's..holla

yea because he is better then rodgers and rivers right T. Homo is overrated tell me one thing he does better then any other QB in the NFL other then bobble snaps and choke every post season they your boys have sucked so bad that winning 1 playoff game in over 10 years was considered a success for you bums.

Came in the league!!!undrafted then go to the 'PROBOWL' everytime.The only time he did'nt go cause he' was hurt!!!! you need to put a 'ASTERISK' next to your last superbowl's cause you didnt earn them. when we go this year' and win you see what a true CHAMPION look's like....

How can you honestly say that we didnt earn our last superbowl I will give you the one we got against seattle but we earned the one against arizona and where were you guys that year... oh yea at home and romo was tossing wittens salad.

steelers earned there superbowl that year. the cowboys wont win. romo is at the right spot at number 9. romo chokes every year

wayne019 wrote:

steelers earned there superbowl that year. the cowboys wont win. romo is at the right spot at number 9. romo chokes every year

OK. REALY DUDE!!!!! who are you? the redskins havent bend on the radar since?? the 90's chief so stay in your lane money.

Romo is at the right spot he should be about 9-12 or around that range. U cant honestly say he should be in the top 5

Ive always had a problem with Maddens QB ratings. There should be a bigger gap between the greats. There are teams that wouldnt be much without thier QB (colts, saints, pats) and there are QB's that wouldnt be much without thier teams(big ben,romo).You cant possibly convince me that the Saints would have won the SB with Ben Roethlisberger behind center. I think they reflect the QB ratings too much on how well the TEAM performs the previous season instead of going off the QB's actual performance. IMO it should go like this....

1. Peyton Manning- 99
2. Drew Brees-99
3. Tom Brady-99
4. Philip Rivers-95
5. Aaron Rogers-88
6. Matt Schaub-88
7. Donovan Mcnabb-84
8. Brett Favre-84
9. Tony Romo-84
10. Ben Roethlisberger/Carson Palmer/Matt Ryan 83

so much swag wrote:

wayne019 wrote:

steelers earned there superbowl that year. the cowboys wont win. romo is at the right spot at number 9. romo chokes every year

OK. REALY DUDE!!!!! who are you? the redskins havent bend on the radar since?? the 90's chief so stay in your lane money.

WTF does the redskins have to do with Tony romos ratings?

matthauganak1 wrote:

so much swag wrote:

wayne019 wrote:

steelers earned there superbowl that year. the cowboys wont win. romo is at the right spot at number 9. romo chokes every year

OK. REALY DUDE!!!!! who are you? the redskins havent bend on the radar since?? the 90's chief so stay in your lane money.

WTF does the redskins have to do with Tony romos ratings?

your mind is young! if you read it CLOSE, you see i was being a smart A$$.LOL

PeytonMvPManning wrote:

Romo is at the right spot he should be about 9-12 or around that range. U cant honestly say he should be in the top 5

YEAH!!! I REALY DO.

I think Schaubs accuracy should be better on the long ball b/c i've never seen him over throw a wr down feild.

The lowest rated qb out the top 10 is an 89 so palmer might be around 87 or 88. So they r all rated pretty high imo.

layinWOOD wrote:

Ive always had a problem with Maddens QB ratings. There should be a bigger gap between the greats. There are teams that wouldnt be much without thier QB (colts, saints, pats) and there are QB's that wouldnt be much without thier teams(big ben,romo).You cant possibly convince me that the Saints would have won the SB with Ben Roethlisberger behind center. I think they reflect the QB ratings too much on how well the TEAM performs the previous season instead of going off the QB's actual performance. IMO it should go like this....

1. Peyton Manning- 99
2. Drew Brees-99
3. Tom Brady-99
4. Philip Rivers-95
5. Aaron Rogers-88
6. Matt Schaub-88
7. Donovan Mcnabb-84
8. Brett Favre-84
9. Tony Romo-84
10. Ben Roethlisberger/Carson Palmer/Matt Ryan 83

if its off last seasons performance... ben should not be anywhere near the bottom... more near rivers and rodgers... check his stats, then watch the green bay game ending, and tell me its not hte exact same play as the superbowl "fluke" catch by holmes... to a different guy, on the opposite side of the field, the guy can ball... get over it... and to put the ink on romo, he should sit solidly at the 10 position... hes terrific in the regular season (with glaring post season issues) and might just have the pieces now for a superbowl run this year... granted theres not some locker room malfunction...

layinWOOD wrote:

Ive always had a problem with Maddens QB ratings. There should be a bigger gap between the greats. There are teams that wouldnt be much without thier QB (colts, saints, pats) and there are QB's that wouldnt be much without thier teams(big ben,romo).You cant possibly convince me that the Saints would have won the SB with Ben Roethlisberger behind center. I think they reflect the QB ratings too much on how well the TEAM performs the previous season instead of going off the QB's actual performance. IMO it should go like this....

1. Peyton Manning- 99
2. Drew Brees-99
3. Tom Brady-99
4. Philip Rivers-95
5. Aaron Rogers-88
6. Matt Schaub-88
7. Donovan Mcnabb-84
8. Brett Favre-84
9. Tony Romo-84
10. Ben Roethlisberger/Carson Palmer/Matt Ryan 83

If you're basing on yearly, I would give Manning, Brees, Favre, Rodger's and McNabb the highest ratings. But I do agree with the rest of your ratings except for maybe bumping up Romo 3-5 points and Brady down about 7

I wish the rating were based on last season performances b/c schaub would be #1 he lead the league in passing yards and he was the MVP of the pro bowl.