Most clutch QB in NFL History

If you can have QB in NFL history to lead your team to a 4th quarter comeback who would you choose and why?

Brett Favre
He leads the NFL all time with 4th Quarter comebacks

elway.

on an elway drive.

Brett Favre

Probably Montana. Greatest QB ever. Elway would be second for sure.

tom brady or peyton manning its close i would take either of them though.

Peyton for sure right now. but in history probly elway or montana

Staubach w/ Dorsett

Dorsett was great at getting to the sideline and Staubach was great at getting him the ball. I remember watching them run that play over and over and it only took a few seconds off the clock.

peyton huh? guess u guys didn't watch the sb i would have to pick montana todays qbs i have no idea. would have been brady but he seems to be on the decline would have been manning but he didn't get it done in the sb and i was rooting for the colts. i do think this the pick six was waynes fault and the dropped pass on the last drive

John Elway
Joe Montana
Brett Favre

In no particular order.

John Elway
&
Jake Plummer

Zx_DMC_DHB_TD_xZ wrote:

peyton huh? guess u guys didn't watch the sb i would have to pick montana todays qbs i have no idea. would have been brady but he seems to be on the decline would have been manning but he didn't get it done in the sb and i was rooting for the colts. i do think this the pick six was waynes fault and the dropped pass on the last drive

u change ur opinion of a 10+ year vet over one drive?

Ron Jaworski no one else comes close

dan marinoooooooo

PeytonMvPManning wrote:

Zx_DMC_DHB_TD_xZ wrote:

peyton huh? guess u guys didn't watch the sb i would have to pick montana todays qbs i have no idea. would have been brady but he seems to be on the decline would have been manning but he didn't get it done in the sb and i was rooting for the colts. i do think this the pick six was waynes fault and the dropped pass on the last drive

u change ur opinion of a 10+ year vet over one drive?

Peyton is one of the best QBs ever, if not the best. However he is not the most clutch. There are quite a few guys i would take if I needed a game winning drive over him.

Oh, no no no no noooooo
Peyton is one of the most clutch QBs ever.
He had more comebacks than anyone last season and probably has more 4th quarter game winning drives than anyone currently playing.
If I had to guess I'd say he will finish his career with the most game winning drives of any QB ever.

He just never gets rattled. That interception in the Superbowl was a gamble on the part of the Saints. Sean Payton said it himself. They had seen that route on film and knew Peyton liked to throw there in that situation, so they gambled and jumped the route. It could have gone to the house the other way, if the gamble backfired. But that is how Sean Payton coached the game. Obviously it wasn't his only gamble.

lol peyton? clutch? then explain how "mr. clutch" has blown coutless playoff games. sorry but if i want somebody to win me a game i want somebody who can do it in any situation, not just the regular season


montana or elway and nobody else is even close

elway did have "the drive"...... so i guess it would be either a tie with brett favre for me

I get your point about playoff games and that is certainly a knock against him. But how bout everybodys favorite here. John Elway we were not sure if he ever was gonna get a ring. But he is mr clutch, explain that.

I remember when they (Denver) played Washington, some no name kid outaa New Mexico tore em up for like 300yds and 4 TDs. The next season Timmy Smith was cut. No explaining it.

I'll try to explain it. Here ya go.

Sh!t happens

I mean C'MON, the Saints won the Superbowl, they must be serving ice water in hell, right about now.

Jk, lol

Let's do a little Elway vs Manning Comparo

Elway winning percentage 64%
Manning winning percentage 66%

Elway in the Superbowl 2-3
Manning 1-1

Playoff Record
Elway 14-7
Manning 9-9
OK, but not until his last two years, before that he was 7-7 and 0-3 in the Superbowl

And as I remember Elway threw tons of interceptions
Both in the Superbowl and the many times he was bounced from the playoffs. He was a gambler. Manning has one interception in the Superbowl.

I remember Elway was the guy who was Mr. Choke. Average regular season stats and horrible failures in the playoffs. Until his last 2 seasons.

And now he is Mr. Clutch.

It didn't happen that way.

Montana is the most clutch. Close thread.

CapnCrunch wrote:

Let's do a little Elway vs Manning Comparo

Elway winning percentage 64%
Manning winning percentage 66%

Elway in the Superbowl 2-3
Manning 1-1

Playoff Record
Elway 14-7
Manning 9-9
OK, but not until his last two years, before that he was 7-7 and 0-3 in the Superbowl

And as I remember Elway threw tons of interceptions
Both in the Superbowl and the many times he was bounced from the playoffs. He was a gambler. Manning has one interception in the Superbowl.

I remember Elway was the guy who was Mr. Choke. Average regular season stats and horrible failures in the playoffs. Until his last 2 seasons.

And now he is Mr. Clutch.

It didn't happen that way.

go ahead and name the GREAT teams elway had around him like manning did. name the superstar TE elway has had his entire career (dallas clark) or the great WR he played with (reggie wayne, marvin harrison). only in half the seasons in wich he was the leading passer did he have a top 10 D. elway had to do EVERYTHING for those teams unlike manning.


drop both of them in the AFC title game on the current colts team (both QB in there prime) and honestly tell me you would rather have manning over elway in a 2 minute drive

Did you say TE
How about the best ever Shannon Sharpe

Its been awhile but I also remember Mark Jackson

As far as who I would want, I don't know what Manning is gonna look like in his last two years. Elway had plenty of growing pains on his way to the top. I used to give my buddy Jose a horrible time about the choke artist that was John Elway, id be hard pressed to pick him now. Between the two, its a tossup for me.

Ill take Staubach, thank you

lol spoken like a boys fan.


after i look at the stats i think its montana by a mile. but i would still take elway over manning


oh and BTW sharp was far from the best TE

winslow? ditka? any of those ring a bell?

montana. lock the thread. 4 super bowl rings. enough said.