Which Safety is better ?

Ed Reed or Brian Dawkins ?

I personally go with Ed Reed. Who do you guys go with ? (Not Just this season, in general.)

who am i gonna say? bet you guys already know that answer! ED REED! however...B Dawk is a baaaaaaddddd boy in his own right.

Ed Reed.. and the real question for whos the best Safety is whos better between Reed and Polamalu!! Polamalu is also better then Dawkins even though Dawkins is bad ass!!

Dawkin's isn't a safety, hes more of a rover like Polamalu.

Bdawk just hits hard, but Reed can actually play zone.

reed just always gets the ball some how. dawkins sort of just fires his team up

I got to go with ED REED over Dawkins

Id take polamalu over any of them. I love the way he can play in the box ut also drop back into coverage.

i would take ed reed over polamalu any day. he is always getting turnovers the only thing polamalu is better at is stopping the run.

I know that, but polamalu is better in coverage then reed is in the box. You cant lose going either way.

Reed is a better player in coverage, but i don't know if you can match they way that Dawkins hits and his intensity, but he does get beat deep more often than a safety should

I was a big fan of sean taylor.
He could ballhawk like ed reed.
And
He could Deliver THE HARDEST HITS in the nfl.

polamalu>reed>dawkins

Since this is in madden talk...

B dawk is way better on madden...

fudopi u gotta be kidding me...

ed reed is the best on the game, then polamalu. i actually like both the cardinals safties as well over dawkins..

hes just too slow for my liking.

ed reed hell you can find someone that can play the box (ie. roy williams) but can you find someone who can do what he does in the deep field????? nope....

Polamalu and B Dawk are both bad boys in their own right...however.....the clear standout is ED REED!! more than just a ball hawk...this cat....is a game changer in a BIG WAY! he is ALWAYS trying to take the ball to the house when he gets a pic. Polamalu and Dawkins are not in his league in that department....PERIOD!

Polamalu is crazy fast in real life he can go from box to 30 yards like that

pkismyname wrote:

I was a big fan of sean taylor.
He could ballhawk like ed reed.
And
He could Deliver THE HARDEST HITS in the nfl.

Best answer ever.

dawkins is 35 this isnt even a question of course its ed reed but b dawk brings the wood and quentin mikell is looking like a stud just learning from dawk hes turned into a pro bowl safety

ball hawking is not everything.

Polamalu ball hawks enough, but he also can blitz stuff run and be anywhere on field in a flash and hit hard

Wheres Polamalu at, hes definitely better than brian dawkins and ed eed in my opinion.

I GOTTA GO WIT ED REED HE A MONSTER BECAUSE WEN HE PICKS DA QBS PASS ITS A 90% CHANCE OF HIM TAKIN IT BACK AND I BARELY SEE B-DAWKINS DOING ANYTHING ANYMORE

xX S3n10r Xx wrote:

I GOTTA GO WIT ED REED HE A MONSTER BECAUSE WEN HE PICKS DA QBS PASS ITS A 90% CHANCE OF HIM TAKIN IT BACK AND I BARELY SEE B-DAWKINS DOING ANYTHING ANYMORE

REED IS AMAZING when it comes to PICK 6...

OGiant23 wrote:

ball hawking is not everything.

bruh...both of these guys are specialist in their own right....Ed is a FS...Troy is a SS. that's two different functions....but....the standout...especially this season....is ED REED....no doubt. both of these cats will be in the secondary for the Pro Bowl. now....it will be tuff to throw on them.